|
Post by Semi-Charmed.Life on Jun 25, 2002 21:51:12 GMT -5
Well, ‘American Idol’ is an American reality TV show that has contestants who compete for the title of the ultimate American Idol. The contestants are chosen based on their vocal talent and their image by a panel of judges (Paula Abdul, Simon, and Randy). If you’ve seen the show, you would have heard many of Simon’s harsh and sometimes cruel comments directed to the contestants. Personally, I feel that most of the contestants have natural talent and that Simon really doesn’t know what he’s talking about despite his extensive background in the music industry. Paula and Randy are a bit more lenient but they too have had their share of sour comments. At the moment, the American audience can choose their favourite contestant and the group is being reduced.
What do you think about the judges, the contestants and the show in general?
|
|
|
Post by :: Natalie :: on Jun 26, 2002 11:04:11 GMT -5
I watched it for the first time last night, as I was just flipping channels. I agree that they are all very talented. Sure, there are always things they can improve on, and as judges you can't say 'good job' to everyone. But Simon is just too rude. He could be nicer about it, like, "It was okay, but I think you need to be more conscious of the rhythm" rather than "it wasn't well done at all. Your rhythm was totally off. Not a good performance". On national television, I think they could be more gracious.
However, Paula Abdul is usually really sweet to the contestants. Finally last night, after Randy and Paula thought the contestant did an excellent job, and Simon made the usual harsh comment, the contestant said, "Really? I'd like to hear you sing a note!" He didn't have much of a response for that. All the other contestants in the waiting room applauded her for that. Hehe. At least it's not up to the judges!
But I think the American audience may judge too much on looks. A few of them were wearing really tiny tops and I have this feeling that may influence some results. But appearance is a big factor in the business, so I'm not one to judge.
|
|
|
Post by Semi-Charmed.Life on Jun 26, 2002 23:49:15 GMT -5
^ Ugh, Simon's a complete cold hearted ass.
Yes, image is very important in picking the true American Idol but I disagree completly and I was quite upset when Simon put down Gil's talent and ability to make it because of his image.
Gil asked out Paula Abdul and she said yes! How cool is that?
My favourite contestants have to be Justin and A.J. They are extremely talented and not to mention very adorable. ;D A.J. is doing it for his mother and I think thats *so* sweet!
|
|
|
Post by LisaRocksYourWorld, yo on Jun 27, 2002 20:50:14 GMT -5
I've just watched this show for the first time the other night... It was pretty entertaining.
I lurve Justin. He has the cutest smile, and the greatest voice. He's the favorite... I have my money on him.
Simon doesn't get on my nerves... I think he's actually helpful is keeping the contestants down to earth, so this early fame doesn't get to their heads too soon. Also, they look good to us, and they have talent, there's no doubt about that, but maybe he sees flaws that we can't. He could be a little nicer about it, but I think it will benefit them in the future.
|
|
|
Post by 1.gurl.revolution on Jul 24, 2002 15:12:18 GMT -5
i agree that what AJ is doing sweet. but one of the contestants (i forget which one) is already a mother. and i know that sometimes you can't help it, i can't help but wonder if that will weigh her down any.
i personally hope that Ryan Star wins. She has a great voice, and a great style of clothes, and great personality. if she doesn't win, then i hope that Christina Christian or Justin wins.
|
|
|
Post by Mrs.Tobey_Maguire on Jul 24, 2002 16:06:29 GMT -5
i've seen this show a few times....i think Simon is just an asshole....most probably, the person who wins will be the best-looking, but i don't really see the winner becoming a huge star or a legend or anything (most likely they'll get they're 15 minutes of fame & then disappear- just like the 2 groups off of the WB's "PopStars" 1 & 2 Series)...oh, & my friend, Kayla, has a crush on the host, Ryan Seacrest (the blonde dude); i have to admit- he's pretty cute!
|
|
|
Post by 1.gurl.revolution on Jul 25, 2002 15:01:56 GMT -5
[glow=yellow,2,300]^yea...the prettiest person is[/i] probably going to win. and that's not right. this show is to find the person who can sing their heart out and proove to america that they are the best. and i'm sure that they will get their 15 minutes of fame, and then within the next 15-20 years they'll be on VH1's Where are they now?![/glow]
|
|
|
Post by Mrs.Tobey_Maguire on Jul 28, 2002 16:53:26 GMT -5
^^LOL about the "Where are they now?" ha ha! ;D
|
|
|
Post by Beautiful.Disaster on Aug 2, 2002 1:41:54 GMT -5
Yeah I saw it for the first time a cpl of days ago. I too think that simon guy is rude and cold hearted. Like when that Nikki girl was done singing, he told her "...you WILL NOT win this competition." and I got pissed at that. She did great and she does have a chance. Anyways, I really like Christina Christian. When she did her thing, I got goosebumps. She was soo good and I really like her. But if she doesn't win, I hape Justin does. He was cool And Tobey, is Ryan Seacrest the one that looks like Brad Pitt? If so, hes hott
|
|
|
Post by Mrs.Tobey_Maguire on Aug 2, 2002 8:20:52 GMT -5
^^yup, Ryan Seacrest is the Brad Pitt lookalike....& i heard he's still single!!! *hee hee*
|
|
|
Post by Beautiful.Disaster on Aug 3, 2002 17:49:40 GMT -5
ooh He's hott! lol When I saw him I was like 'OMG is that Brad Pitt?!'
|
|
|
Post by ¤SassySteph0248¤ on Sept 2, 2002 13:31:58 GMT -5
I wanted Nikki to win because she seemed to have more of a variety & I reeaally liked her voice, but now that she's gone I'm not even going to watch it. I hope Justin wins over that Kelly girl though, she kinda seems like a Britney wannabe or something....
|
|
|
Post by LisaRocksYourWorld, yo on Sept 2, 2002 15:20:37 GMT -5
So it's down to two now! And I couldn't be happier, because those are the two I'd really like to win.
As far as vocal abilities go, Kelly has more talent. Also, I can't see her ever becoming something along the lines of Britney Spears. She just seems too advanced for that.
I do think Justin is going to win. He has more charisma, a nice voice, and he can really work a crowd.
|
|
|
Post by Keista1 on Sept 3, 2002 17:31:11 GMT -5
I liked Tamyra soooo much! I had my mouth hanging open the night she got voted off. Nikki can't sing worth crap, she sings worse than Britney Spears, which is REALLY bad. I like Kelly, she seems like she would be a country singer. I don't know why, she just does. I like Justin too, everyone is gaga over his hair, and I think it is cool, but it is a lil much! He needs a LIL trim! That is it, just to make it even, and I don't know, nicer looking? I think it would be hilarious if he would just like shave it off! That would be great! I think Kelly is going to win, she has more talent, and the audience seems to love her!
|
|
|
Post by funkygirlk16 on Sept 3, 2002 17:51:29 GMT -5
I just wish I tuned in sooner. I thought it would be another survivor/teenybopper show. So, I didnt watch. And not Im sad because I didn't!
|
|